下载App
资质规则
旅行
账户
Alvaro_EER
Interesting experience. Unfortunately some comments should not have been made
Mas Molla Des de 1338的点评
点评：As part of a family holiday, because we were in the area, and weather was not great to go to the beach, we decided to visit the winery, given the great reviews and strong recommendations. We were 8 adults. Process to book the visit was per email, fast and straightforward. We were told that tour was going to be in Spanish, what was perfect, because we are all Spanish native speakers. When we arrived, there was quite a debate on whether the tour should be in Spanish or Catalan, and finally it did end up being 70% Spanish and 30% Catalan, mainly because one particular couple attending pushed for it to be in Catalan. The visit itself was very interesting and a good learning about wine production using traditional methods. Really impressive and great to see the passion they put on this. And for wine lovers like us, it was mind-opening.
However, during the visit, the guide (one member of the family which owns the place) made some heavily politically loaded comments, which in my view don't belong to a tour, mainly when you don't know the audience. I understand the sensitivities in Spain around Catalonia and Madrid around (i.e) the language, and also the pressure that small companies like this face in the modern world, but comments around "the right of farmers to block roads to try to get paid fair price for their products" or "we are victims of the big corporations managed by people who run agri-business with an IPhone whilst driving a Ferrari without knowing much about it" are ok to be made in a closed circle of people, between well known friends, but definitely not in a tour where you simply don't know who is in the audience. I admire the commitment and passion, but as said, some comments were out of tone and out of place, and simply didn't land very well.
However, during the visit, the guide (one member of the family which owns the place) made some heavily politically loaded comments, which in my view don't belong to a tour, mainly when you don't know the audience. I understand the sensitivities in Spain around Catalonia and Madrid around (i.e) the language, and also the pressure that small companies like this face in the modern world, but comments around "the right of farmers to block roads to try to get paid fair price for their products" or "we are victims of the big corporations managed by people who run agri-business with an IPhone whilst driving a Ferrari without knowing much about it" are ok to be made in a closed circle of people, between well known friends, but definitely not in a tour where you simply don't know who is in the audience. I admire the commitment and passion, but as said, some comments were out of tone and out of place, and simply didn't land very well.
翻译：由于我们一家人正好在附近度假，而且天气不太适合去海滩，所以我们决定去参观这家酒庄，因为之前看到过很多好评和强烈推荐。我们一行八位成人。预订过程是通过邮件进行的，快捷方便。我们被告知参观会用西班牙语进行，这正合我们意，因为我们都是以西班牙语为母语的人。然而，当我们到达酒庄后，关于参观语言应该是西班牙语还是加泰罗尼亚语，大家争论了一番，最终决定用西班牙语讲解70%，加泰罗尼亚语讲解30%，主要是因为有一对夫妇坚持要用加泰罗尼亚语。参观本身非常有趣，让我们了解了传统的葡萄酒酿造方法。酒庄主人对葡萄酒的热情令人印象深刻，也让我们大开眼界。对于像我们这样的葡萄酒爱好者来说，这次参观更是令人大开眼界。
但是，在参观过程中，导游（酒庄主人家族的成员之一）发表了一些带有强烈政治色彩的言论，在我看来，这些言论并不适合在参观讲解时出现，尤其是在不了解听众的情况下。我理解西班牙加泰罗尼亚和马德里地区（例如语言方面）的敏感性，也理解像这样的小公司在当今世界面临的压力。但是，关于“农民有权封锁道路以争取公平的农产品价格”或“我们是那些开着法拉利、用iPhone管理农业企业却对汽车一窍不通的人的受害者”之类的言论，在亲密的朋友圈里说是可以的，但在你根本不知道观众是谁的巡回演出中，绝对不合适。我欣赏你们的投入和热情，但正如我所说，有些言论语气不当，场合不合适，让人难以接受。
但是，在参观过程中，导游（酒庄主人家族的成员之一）发表了一些带有强烈政治色彩的言论，在我看来，这些言论并不适合在参观讲解时出现，尤其是在不了解听众的情况下。我理解西班牙加泰罗尼亚和马德里地区（例如语言方面）的敏感性，也理解像这样的小公司在当今世界面临的压力。但是，关于“农民有权封锁道路以争取公平的农产品价格”或“我们是那些开着法拉利、用iPhone管理农业企业却对汽车一窍不通的人的受害者”之类的言论，在亲密的朋友圈里说是可以的，但在你根本不知道观众是谁的巡回演出中，绝对不合适。我欣赏你们的投入和热情，但正如我所说，有些言论语气不当，场合不合适，让人难以接受。
© 2026 Tripadvisor 版权所有。
部分照片由 VFM Leonardo 提供。
TripAdvisor公司对外部网站的内容一概不负责。优惠价格中不含税和其他费用。
ICP证：沪B2-20200433
沪ICP备20013175号
沪公网安备31010502005427号鹰程信息技术（上海）有限公司
