点评:I've been in Sibaltan for 4 days and made 12 dives with this shop. I've chosen Sibaltan because people on Reddit say diving here is better than El Nido. Didn't dive in El Nido so can't compare. But here diving is great. The chief attraction is manta site: 4 cleaning stations, during the season (starts at about 1 Mar) mantas are seen every day or almost every day, usually in the morning, rarely in the afternoon. I dove it 4 times: 3 mornings and 1 afternoon - saw mantas every morning but didn't see in the afternoon dive. But off season mantas can be absent for months, so don't go there outside of the season. Some of the other sites have really beautiful corals. Also they have a wonderful site called Shark Highway, it's a special excursion but it's worth it - we saw plenty of sharks and also fabulous corals.
There are 2 dive shops in Sibaltan: Mobula and Dive Sibaltan. Owner of Mobula told me that he and his partners owned Dive Sibaltan before and there was only their shop there, but then they decided to split up because his partners wanted to move to a larger place while he wanted to stay at the old location. So, TripAdvisor's old reviews for Dive Sibaltan are pretty much applicable to Mobula, too, since it's run by the person who ran Dive Sibaltan before and Mobula's shop was Dive Sibaltan before. Now Dive Sibaltan seems to get a lot less clients than Mobula. I've been on 6 dive trips and most times we saw either no boat from Dive Sibaltan, or on more busy days there were 2 boats from Mobula and 1 from Dive Sibaltan on the manta spot.
Before choosing dive shop I asked a number of questions to both Dive Sibaltan and Mobula in WhatsApp. Answers to most questions were identical, but here are the differences I found, based on which I chose Mobula:
1) Mobula has better food in the surface interval - usually Burgers (!!!), or banana bread which is quite filling, while Dive Sibaltan told me they provide only fruits and biscuits (I do like to have proper food between the dives),
2) Mobula owner told me I didn't have to transfer deposit to reserve fun dives, just tell them when I'll be there and then show up (check with owner if it's still true in your case though),
3) For some reason Dive Sibaltan said that Shark Highway can only be visited by Advanced divers, while Mobula says that Open Water level is enough. It's not deep so I agree with Mobula, not sure why Dive Sibaltan thinks this way,
4) Dive Sibaltan accepts credit cards, while Mobula - only Wise or PayPal.
Both companies are equally slow to respond in WhatsApp, takes them hours, so be patient.
My experience with Mobula has been very good overall. The owner is a very nice guy, funny and relaxed. Guides are also very nice people (all foreigners). They do point out the small stuff, as well as the large stuff (obviously). I've seen no problems with safety or anything else. However, if you want to dive there multiple days (as I did), be sure to inform them beforehand that you want to visit different dive sites, they might be able to accommodate you, or maybe not. They have about a dozen of sites, but their operation is tailored to people who dive with them only for one day, because majority of their clients stay in El Nido and it's hard to come to Sibaltan on multiple days (it's 1 hour of driving in one direction), and most clients just want to see the mantas. So they go to the manta point in both morning and afternoon trip. They have 2 trips: morning and afternoon, each makes 2 dives, it's possible to go on both trips on the same day, but each of these trips normally starts with manta point and the second one is often the same site called Wild Wild West. So, if you want to dive different places be sure to let them know. I did 12 dives with them and saw only 5 different spots.
One small strange issue: their mask cleaning solution is toothpaste (!). I've never seen this before. I wonder what made them choose such a substance which is hard to put on and even harder to clean from the mask properly. Usually all dive shops / boats I've been to use either baby shampoo, liquid soap or dishwasher liquid, all heavily diluted (like 1 : 20 or so), these are the best substances to clean mask with. Me and someone else experienced problems with mask fogging on the first day.
It seems, Mobula is not very good at upselling special trips. Shark Highway is a great dive site, but one guide said they haven't been there for months, as it requires 5 divers minimum. It's also possible to do night dives in Sibaltan. It seems most of their clients simply don't know about these: when I talked to other divers and told them about these options, they became interested, none knew about it before I told them. Nobody "sold" the trips to the people I talked to. We made the shark trip seemingly only because I knew about it beforehand. Mobula could sell these trips more if they mention it to everyone, or have printed information describing these in the shop. This would benefit everyone.
In 12 dives we saw: plenty of mantas, blue-spotted stingrays, some nudi branches, beautiful corals, plenty of sharks (only on the sharks trip), pufferfish, anemons, lionfish, turtles, batfish, moray eels, cuttlefish !!!
翻译:我在西巴尔坦待了4天,在这家潜水店潜水了12次。我选择西巴尔坦是因为Reddit上有人说这里的潜水比爱妮岛好。我没有在爱妮岛潜水,所以无法比较。但这里的潜水体验非常棒。最吸引人的是蝠鲼聚集地:这里有4个清洁站。在潜季(大约从3月1日开始),蝠鲼几乎每天都能看到,通常是在早上,很少在下午。我潜过4次:3次早上和1次下午——每天早上都看到蝠鲼,但下午的潜水没看到。但淡季蝠鲼可能会几个月都不见踪影,所以不要在淡季之外去那里。其他一些潜水点的珊瑚也非常漂亮。他们还有一个名为“鲨鱼高速公路”的潜水点,虽然是一次特别的旅行,但绝对值得——我们看到了很多鲨鱼和美丽的珊瑚。
西巴尔坦有两家潜水店:Mobula和Dive Sibaltan。 Mobula 的老板告诉我,他和合伙人之前拥有 Dive Sibaltan,那里只有他们一家店,但后来他们决定分道扬镳,因为他的合伙人想搬到更大的地方,而他想留在原址。所以,TripAdvisor 上以前对 Dive Sibaltan 的评价基本也适用于 Mobula,因为这家店的老板是之前经营 Dive Sibaltan 的人,而 Mobula 的店以前就是 Dive Sibaltan。现在 Dive Sibaltan 的客户似乎比 Mobula 少很多。我参加过 6 次潜水旅行,大多数时候我们要么看不到 Dive Sibaltan 的船,要么在比较忙的日子里,在蝠鲼捕捞点有 2 艘 Mobula 的船和 1 艘 Dive Sibaltan 的船。
在选择潜店之前,我在 WhatsApp 上向 Dive Sibaltan 和 Mobula 都问了一些问题。大多数问题的答案都一样,但我发现了一些差异,基于这些差异我选择了Mobula:
1)Mobula在水面休息期间提供更好的食物——通常是汉堡(!!!)或者香蕉面包,很容易让人饱腹,而Dive Sibaltan告诉我他们只提供水果和饼干(我确实喜欢在潜水间隙吃点东西)。
2)Mobula的老板告诉我,预订趣味潜水不需要支付押金,只要告诉他们我什么时候到,然后就去就可以了(不过,如果你的情况仍然如此,请与老板确认)。
3)不知为何,Dive Sibaltan说鲨鱼高速公路只有高级潜水员才能进入,而Mobula说开放水域就足够了。那里的水不深,所以我同意Mobula的说法,不知道Dive Sibaltan为什么这么认为。
4)Dive Sibaltan接受信用卡,而Mobula只接受Wise或PayPal。
两家公司在WhatsApp上的回复都一样慢,需要几个小时,所以请耐心等待。
我在Mobula的体验总体来说非常好。老板人很好,风趣幽默,让人放松。导游也都很友善(都是外国人)。他们会指出各种小细节,当然也会指出各种大问题(当然)。我没有发现任何安全或其他方面的问题。但是,如果你想在那里潜水多日(就像我一样),一定要提前告知他们你想去不同的潜点,他们或许可以安排,也或许不行。他们有大约十几个潜点,但他们的运营模式是针对只潜水一天的顾客量身定制的,因为大多数顾客都住在爱妮岛,很难连续几天去西巴尔坦岛(单程开车要一个小时),而且大多数顾客只是想看看蝠鲼。所以他们早上和下午都会去蝠鲼点。他们有两次行程:上午和下午,每次潜水两次,可以在同一天进行两次行程,但每次行程通常都从蝠鲼点出发,第二次通常是同一个叫做Wild Wild West的地点。所以,如果你想去不同的地方潜水,一定要告诉他们。我和他们一起潜了12次,只看到了5个不同的地点。
一个小问题:他们的面罩清洁液是牙膏!我以前从未见过。我想知道他们为什么选择这种难以涂抹,更难以从面罩上彻底清除的物质。通常我去过的所有潜店/潜水船都会使用婴儿洗发水、液体肥皂或洗洁精,都是高度稀释的(比如1:20左右),这些是清洁面罩的最佳物质。我和其他人第一天就遇到了面罩起雾的问题。
看来,Mobula不太擅长推销特价行程。鲨鱼高速公路是个很棒的潜水点,但一位导游说他们已经好几个月没去了,因为那里至少需要5名潜水员。在西巴尔坦也可以进行夜潜。看来他们的大多数客户根本不知道这些:当我和其他潜水员交流并告诉他们这些选择时,他们都很感兴趣,在我告诉他们之前,他们根本不知道。没有人向我交流过的人“推销”这些行程。我们参加鲨鱼之旅似乎只是因为我事先知道。如果蝠鲼(Mobula)向所有人宣传,或者在店里印制相关信息,就能更好地推销这些行程。这将使每个人都受益。
在 12 次潜水中,我们看到了:大量的蝠鲼、蓝点黄貂鱼、一些裸鳃类、美丽的珊瑚、大量的鲨鱼(仅在鲨鱼之旅中)、河豚、海葵、狮子鱼、海龟、蝙蝠鱼、海鳗、乌贼!!!