下载App
旅行
账户
wendybQ699SH
Not what it was
Thackray Museum Of Medicine的点评
点评：Last went about 20 years ago with my daughters - a great museum then that my daughters still remember. This recent visit was with 11 and 6 year old grandsons. What a disappointment.
The positives: this Victorian building has been beautifully renovated. Some of the old exhibits are still there ( e.g. ‘disease street’, the surgery ‘theatre’, and lots of surgical instruments and devices (though mostly still in the same (now rather dated) display cases I think.) A few things were just parked in a corridor, with minimal signage - e.g. the iron lung machines .
The negatives: looks like money has been splashed on a newly curated display area (the first you go in to), brightly illustrated with lots of coloured plastic. It is dedicated to poo. I think it is supposed to capture the imagination of kids. Failed miserably with my two grandsons, despite my efforts. There is a further bright plastic exhibition board about poo on the top floor - why? There is also a lot of ‘woke’ throughout the museum e.g. climate change gets a room of its own, sexual health has an animated video with trans topics and using trans vocabulary (aubergines anyone?), a room lauding the NHS with banners about how the NHS has saved the lives of mothers in childbirth (apparently missing the irony of the current investigation into maternity services in Leeds), and a quote from the first Leeds Pride March, in large lettering, in a wall display about other topics. I didn’t bring my grandsons to the museum to be indoctrinated about these topics.
On arrival we were informed the museum is ‘pay as you’ feel, but that it operates as a charity and the recommended payment is £12 per person. So we paid £48. On top of £2 per hour parking. Good value? Nope.
The positives: this Victorian building has been beautifully renovated. Some of the old exhibits are still there ( e.g. ‘disease street’, the surgery ‘theatre’, and lots of surgical instruments and devices (though mostly still in the same (now rather dated) display cases I think.) A few things were just parked in a corridor, with minimal signage - e.g. the iron lung machines .
The negatives: looks like money has been splashed on a newly curated display area (the first you go in to), brightly illustrated with lots of coloured plastic. It is dedicated to poo. I think it is supposed to capture the imagination of kids. Failed miserably with my two grandsons, despite my efforts. There is a further bright plastic exhibition board about poo on the top floor - why? There is also a lot of ‘woke’ throughout the museum e.g. climate change gets a room of its own, sexual health has an animated video with trans topics and using trans vocabulary (aubergines anyone?), a room lauding the NHS with banners about how the NHS has saved the lives of mothers in childbirth (apparently missing the irony of the current investigation into maternity services in Leeds), and a quote from the first Leeds Pride March, in large lettering, in a wall display about other topics. I didn’t bring my grandsons to the museum to be indoctrinated about these topics.
On arrival we were informed the museum is ‘pay as you’ feel, but that it operates as a charity and the recommended payment is £12 per person. So we paid £48. On top of £2 per hour parking. Good value? Nope.
翻译：上次去大概是20年前，我和女儿们一起去的——当时那是一个很棒的博物馆，我女儿们至今仍记忆犹新。最近这次去的时候，我带着11岁和6岁的孙子们。真是令人失望。
优点：这座维多利亚风格的建筑经过了精美的翻修。一些旧展品仍然在那里（例如“疾病街”、手术“剧院”和许多手术器械和设备（尽管我认为它们大多仍放在相同的（现在相当过时的）展示柜中。）一些东西只是停放在走廊里，几乎没有标识 - 例如铁肺机。 缺点：看起来有人花钱新策划了一个展示区（你进去的第一个展示区），用大量彩色塑料进行了明亮的说明。它是专门关于便便的。我认为它应该能吸引孩子们的想象力。尽管我努力了，但对我的两个孙子来说却惨败。顶楼还有一个关于便便的明亮塑料展板 - 为什么？整个博物馆还有很多“觉醒”的东西，例如气候变化有自己的房间，性健康有一个包含跨性别主题和使用跨性别词汇的动画视频（有人要茄子吗？），一个赞扬 NHS 的房间挂着横幅，讲述 NHS 如何挽救了分娩母亲的生命（显然没注意到利兹目前正在进行的针对产科服务的调查的讽刺意味），以及在墙上用大字引用的第一次利兹骄傲游行的引文，内容涉及其他话题。我带孙子来博物馆可不是为了接受这些话题的灌输。
我们到达后被告知，博物馆实行“随心付费”制度，但它是慈善机构运营的，建议每人支付12英镑。所以我们付了48英镑。还加收每小时2英镑的停车费。划算吗？不划算。
优点：这座维多利亚风格的建筑经过了精美的翻修。一些旧展品仍然在那里（例如“疾病街”、手术“剧院”和许多手术器械和设备（尽管我认为它们大多仍放在相同的（现在相当过时的）展示柜中。）一些东西只是停放在走廊里，几乎没有标识 - 例如铁肺机。 缺点：看起来有人花钱新策划了一个展示区（你进去的第一个展示区），用大量彩色塑料进行了明亮的说明。它是专门关于便便的。我认为它应该能吸引孩子们的想象力。尽管我努力了，但对我的两个孙子来说却惨败。顶楼还有一个关于便便的明亮塑料展板 - 为什么？整个博物馆还有很多“觉醒”的东西，例如气候变化有自己的房间，性健康有一个包含跨性别主题和使用跨性别词汇的动画视频（有人要茄子吗？），一个赞扬 NHS 的房间挂着横幅，讲述 NHS 如何挽救了分娩母亲的生命（显然没注意到利兹目前正在进行的针对产科服务的调查的讽刺意味），以及在墙上用大字引用的第一次利兹骄傲游行的引文，内容涉及其他话题。我带孙子来博物馆可不是为了接受这些话题的灌输。
我们到达后被告知，博物馆实行“随心付费”制度，但它是慈善机构运营的，建议每人支付12英镑。所以我们付了48英镑。还加收每小时2英镑的停车费。划算吗？不划算。
© 2025 Tripadvisor 版权所有。
部分照片由 VFM Leonardo 提供。
TripAdvisor公司对外部网站的内容一概不负责。优惠价格中不含税和其他费用。
ICP证：沪B2-20200433
沪ICP备20013175号
沪公网安备31010502005427号鹰程信息技术（上海）有限公司
