下载App
资质规则
旅行
账户
Culture3337082****
Get rid of Dolphin Quest
National Museum of Bermuda的点评
点评：I visited the National Museum of Bermuda expecting a world-class historical experience, but left utterly heartbroken and disgusted. You do not need to pay for a Dolphin Quest ticket to see the reality of this facility; you can look right down into the enclosures from the museum grounds. Seeing these highly intelligent, wide-ranging ocean mammals restricted to tiny, shallow limestone channels built into old 19th-century military moats is devastating.
When I directly questioned a trainer about the tiny footprint of these tanks and the ethics of captivity, his response was a masterclass in corporate deception, rehearsed PR scripts, and blatant lies.
First, he tried to excuse the microscopic enclosures by claiming the facility uses "natural ocean water" and that these dolphins are an ecotype that naturally "prefers shallow water." This is an absolute insult to marine biology. Pumping tidal ocean water through iron gates changes the chemistry of the water, but it does absolutely nothing to change the confinement. It creates a horrific acoustic prison where the dolphins' hypersensitive echolocation clicks constantly bounce off solid limestone fortress walls just a few meters away.
Furthermore, while wild coastal dolphins utilize shallow estuaries, their natural home ranges span hundreds of square kilometers, and wild dolphins swim up to 100 kilometers (60+ miles) every single day. In fact, researchers tracking wild dolphins right here in Bermuda have clocked them diving to depths of over 1,000 meters (3,300 feet). No wild dolphin on earth would ever choose to stay inside a shallow stone moat; the only reason they are "shallow-water dolphins" is because they are physically blocked from leaving.
Second, when asked about captive breeding, the trainer claimed they don't do it "purposely" but "can if they want." This is an outright lie. Dolphin Quest operates a highly aggressive, meticulously managed captive breeding and artificial insemination program. Modern marine facilities can easily prevent breeding through physical separation or contraception; Dolphin Quest actively chooses to breed them to restock their commercial tourist pools with new generations of innocent babies born into permanent confinement.
Finally, when I confronted him about the obvious signs of severe captive distress visible in the pools-such as dolphins "logging" (floating completely lifelessly at the surface out of sheer, mind-numbing boredom) and bodies covered in "rake marks" (deep tooth scratches from inescapable social aggression in a tiny tank) -he resorted to gaslighting, feigning total ignorance to protect their tourist revenue. I witnessed the endless swimming in circles that they know very well is a sign of distress. One of the dolphins held here, a 52-year-old wild-caught female named Cirrus, has spent nearly half a century in captivity. Staff exploit her specialized, past U.S. Navy training to run open-ocean exercises, using her to claim the dolphins "have the option to go to the ocean." The reality is that the vast majority of the dolphins in this tiny footprint will never experience the open sea, and Cirrus herself was actively recaptured and forced back into this moat after escaping during a hurricane in 1999.
A fixed anatomical smile is not an indicator of happiness or well-being. Do not let the "smiling" facade or the corporate greenwashing trick you. This facility belongs in the past, not in 2026. I urge the National Museum of Bermuda to reconsider its partnership with a commercial dolphin attraction, and urge all travelers to refuse to give this place a single dime of their money.
When I directly questioned a trainer about the tiny footprint of these tanks and the ethics of captivity, his response was a masterclass in corporate deception, rehearsed PR scripts, and blatant lies.
First, he tried to excuse the microscopic enclosures by claiming the facility uses "natural ocean water" and that these dolphins are an ecotype that naturally "prefers shallow water." This is an absolute insult to marine biology. Pumping tidal ocean water through iron gates changes the chemistry of the water, but it does absolutely nothing to change the confinement. It creates a horrific acoustic prison where the dolphins' hypersensitive echolocation clicks constantly bounce off solid limestone fortress walls just a few meters away.
Furthermore, while wild coastal dolphins utilize shallow estuaries, their natural home ranges span hundreds of square kilometers, and wild dolphins swim up to 100 kilometers (60+ miles) every single day. In fact, researchers tracking wild dolphins right here in Bermuda have clocked them diving to depths of over 1,000 meters (3,300 feet). No wild dolphin on earth would ever choose to stay inside a shallow stone moat; the only reason they are "shallow-water dolphins" is because they are physically blocked from leaving.
Second, when asked about captive breeding, the trainer claimed they don't do it "purposely" but "can if they want." This is an outright lie. Dolphin Quest operates a highly aggressive, meticulously managed captive breeding and artificial insemination program. Modern marine facilities can easily prevent breeding through physical separation or contraception; Dolphin Quest actively chooses to breed them to restock their commercial tourist pools with new generations of innocent babies born into permanent confinement.
Finally, when I confronted him about the obvious signs of severe captive distress visible in the pools-such as dolphins "logging" (floating completely lifelessly at the surface out of sheer, mind-numbing boredom) and bodies covered in "rake marks" (deep tooth scratches from inescapable social aggression in a tiny tank) -he resorted to gaslighting, feigning total ignorance to protect their tourist revenue. I witnessed the endless swimming in circles that they know very well is a sign of distress. One of the dolphins held here, a 52-year-old wild-caught female named Cirrus, has spent nearly half a century in captivity. Staff exploit her specialized, past U.S. Navy training to run open-ocean exercises, using her to claim the dolphins "have the option to go to the ocean." The reality is that the vast majority of the dolphins in this tiny footprint will never experience the open sea, and Cirrus herself was actively recaptured and forced back into this moat after escaping during a hurricane in 1999.
A fixed anatomical smile is not an indicator of happiness or well-being. Do not let the "smiling" facade or the corporate greenwashing trick you. This facility belongs in the past, not in 2026. I urge the National Museum of Bermuda to reconsider its partnership with a commercial dolphin attraction, and urge all travelers to refuse to give this place a single dime of their money.
翻译：我原本期望能在百慕大国家博物馆获得一次世界级的历史体验，结果却满怀心碎与厌恶地离开了。其实你无需购买“海豚探秘之旅”的门票也能看清这家机构的真实面貌：从博物馆的场地就能直接俯瞰那些圈养区。看到这些极其聪明且习惯在广阔海域遨游的海洋哺乳动物，如今却被困在19世纪军事护城河改造而成的狭窄浅水石灰岩水道中，实在令人痛心不已。当我直接询问训练员这些水箱为何如此狭小，以及圈养海豚的伦理问题时，他的回答堪称企业欺骗手段的典范——全是事先排练好的公关说辞与赤裸裸的谎言。
起初，他试图为这些小得可怜的水箱辩解，声称养殖场使用的是“天然海水”，这些海豚属于天生“喜欢浅水环境”的物种。这种说法完全是对海洋生物学的亵渎。将潮汐海水通过铁门泵入后，虽然水的化学性质会发生改变，但这完全无法改变其封闭状态。这样一来便形成了一个可怕的“声学牢笼”：海豚们极度敏感的回声定位声呐信号不断在仅几米之遥的坚硬石灰岩壁垒上反射回来。
此外，虽然野生的沿海海豚会利用浅水河口作为栖息地，但它们自然的活动范围实际上涵盖了数百平方公里。野生海豚每天能游动100公里（60多英里）。事实上，在百慕大对野生海豚进行追踪的研究人员记录到，它们能下潜到1000多米（3300英尺）的深海。地球上没有任何一只野生海豚会愿意待在浅浅的石砌护城河里；它们之所以被称为“浅水海豚”，仅仅是因为身体条件限制了它们离开。
其次，当被问及圈养繁殖的问题时。那位训练师声称他们并非“故意”这么做，但“如果愿意也可以这么做”。这完全是谎言。Dolphin Quest实施着一项极具侵略性且管理严密的圈养繁殖与人工授精计划。现代化的海洋馆其实完全可以通过物理隔离或使用避孕手段来防止繁殖；但Dolphin Quest却刻意选择让海豚繁殖，以便向那些商业旅游景点提供一批又一批生来便被囚禁在其中的无辜小海豚。当我向他指出那些明显表明海豚处于极度痛苦状态的现象时——比如海豚“漂浮不动”（纯粹因为无聊至极而毫无生气地漂浮在水面），以及身上带有“抓痕”（在狭小的水池中遭受无处可逃的社会性攻击后留下的深深齿痕）——他却耍起心理操控的把戏，装作全然不知来维护其旅游业收益。我也亲眼目睹了那些海豚无休止地绕圈游泳，而它们自己也心知肚明，这就是痛苦与焦虑的表现。在这里饲养的鲸豚中，有一只52岁的雌性海豚，名叫“西里斯”，它是野生状态下被捕获的。它已在人工饲养环境中度过了近半个世纪。工作人员利用它曾接受过的美国海军训练专长来开展远洋训练，并借此宣称这些海豚“有机会重返大海”。然而事实上，在这个狭小空间里生活的绝大多数海豚都永远无法体验到真正的海洋生活。Cirrus也曾在1999年的一场飓风中逃脱，但随后又被强行抓回，被迫回到这个“护城河”中。
面无表情的“微笑”并不能代表快乐或幸福。千万别被这种“面带微笑”的表象或企业的绿色营销手段所迷惑。这家设施本就属于过去，而不应存在于2026年。我恳请百慕大国家博物馆重新考虑与这家商业性海豚馆的合作关系，同时也呼吁所有游客切勿向这个地方支付一分钱。
起初，他试图为这些小得可怜的水箱辩解，声称养殖场使用的是“天然海水”，这些海豚属于天生“喜欢浅水环境”的物种。这种说法完全是对海洋生物学的亵渎。将潮汐海水通过铁门泵入后，虽然水的化学性质会发生改变，但这完全无法改变其封闭状态。这样一来便形成了一个可怕的“声学牢笼”：海豚们极度敏感的回声定位声呐信号不断在仅几米之遥的坚硬石灰岩壁垒上反射回来。
此外，虽然野生的沿海海豚会利用浅水河口作为栖息地，但它们自然的活动范围实际上涵盖了数百平方公里。野生海豚每天能游动100公里（60多英里）。事实上，在百慕大对野生海豚进行追踪的研究人员记录到，它们能下潜到1000多米（3300英尺）的深海。地球上没有任何一只野生海豚会愿意待在浅浅的石砌护城河里；它们之所以被称为“浅水海豚”，仅仅是因为身体条件限制了它们离开。
其次，当被问及圈养繁殖的问题时。那位训练师声称他们并非“故意”这么做，但“如果愿意也可以这么做”。这完全是谎言。Dolphin Quest实施着一项极具侵略性且管理严密的圈养繁殖与人工授精计划。现代化的海洋馆其实完全可以通过物理隔离或使用避孕手段来防止繁殖；但Dolphin Quest却刻意选择让海豚繁殖，以便向那些商业旅游景点提供一批又一批生来便被囚禁在其中的无辜小海豚。当我向他指出那些明显表明海豚处于极度痛苦状态的现象时——比如海豚“漂浮不动”（纯粹因为无聊至极而毫无生气地漂浮在水面），以及身上带有“抓痕”（在狭小的水池中遭受无处可逃的社会性攻击后留下的深深齿痕）——他却耍起心理操控的把戏，装作全然不知来维护其旅游业收益。我也亲眼目睹了那些海豚无休止地绕圈游泳，而它们自己也心知肚明，这就是痛苦与焦虑的表现。在这里饲养的鲸豚中，有一只52岁的雌性海豚，名叫“西里斯”，它是野生状态下被捕获的。它已在人工饲养环境中度过了近半个世纪。工作人员利用它曾接受过的美国海军训练专长来开展远洋训练，并借此宣称这些海豚“有机会重返大海”。然而事实上，在这个狭小空间里生活的绝大多数海豚都永远无法体验到真正的海洋生活。Cirrus也曾在1999年的一场飓风中逃脱，但随后又被强行抓回，被迫回到这个“护城河”中。
面无表情的“微笑”并不能代表快乐或幸福。千万别被这种“面带微笑”的表象或企业的绿色营销手段所迷惑。这家设施本就属于过去，而不应存在于2026年。我恳请百慕大国家博物馆重新考虑与这家商业性海豚馆的合作关系，同时也呼吁所有游客切勿向这个地方支付一分钱。
© 2026 Tripadvisor 版权所有。
部分照片由 VFM Leonardo 提供。
TripAdvisor公司对外部网站的内容一概不负责。优惠价格中不含税和其他费用。
ICP证：沪B2-20200433
沪ICP备20013175号
沪公网安备31010502005427号鹰程信息技术（上海）有限公司
