下载App
资质规则
旅行
账户
Will C
Transcends the narrative
Whitman Mission的点评
点评：The myth of the noble savage is alive and well in our national park service. The facts are that, as was typical of Native American tribes, the Cayuse practiced slavery and brutally subjugated their women rather than being ethereal and spiritual stewards of the earth
Yet here the Cayuse are presented more as magical elves than actual human beings. The narrative being promoted attempts to justify the murder of the Whitmans by claiming the Cayuse had their own reality, whereby Dr Whitman had summoned evil spirits to give them the measles. Imagine if we used this same logic to justify the puritans burning women as witches simply because they really believed them to be witches or justifying pogroms against Jews during the bubonic plague because of a sincere belief that they were poisoning the wells! In an attempt to counteract one false narrative the wokesters have merely substituted an equally false mirror image of that which they claim to detest.
That being said, it is a lovely and peaceful place. Just ignore the woke propaganda and meditate on the real history of flawed and yet worthy human beings who now rest in peace.
Yet here the Cayuse are presented more as magical elves than actual human beings. The narrative being promoted attempts to justify the murder of the Whitmans by claiming the Cayuse had their own reality, whereby Dr Whitman had summoned evil spirits to give them the measles. Imagine if we used this same logic to justify the puritans burning women as witches simply because they really believed them to be witches or justifying pogroms against Jews during the bubonic plague because of a sincere belief that they were poisoning the wells! In an attempt to counteract one false narrative the wokesters have merely substituted an equally false mirror image of that which they claim to detest.
That being said, it is a lovely and peaceful place. Just ignore the woke propaganda and meditate on the real history of flawed and yet worthy human beings who now rest in peace.
翻译：“高贵的野蛮人”神话在我们的国家公园管理局依然盛行。事实是，卡尤斯人（Cayuse）如同其他美洲原住民部落一样，实行奴隶制，残酷地奴役妇女，而非神圣的土地守护者。
然而，在这里，卡尤斯人却被描绘成魔法精灵，而非真正的人类。这种叙事试图为惠特曼夫妇的谋杀辩护，声称卡尤斯人拥有自己的世界，惠特曼医生召唤了邪灵，使他们染上麻疹。试想一下，如果我们用同样的逻辑来为清教徒烧死妇女的行为辩护，仅仅因为他们真心相信她们是女巫；或者为黑死病期间对犹太人的迫害辩护，仅仅因为他们真诚地相信犹太人在水井里投毒！为了反驳一个错误的叙事，觉醒派仅仅用一个同样错误的镜像来代替，而这个镜像正是他们声称憎恶的。
即便如此，这里仍然是一个美丽而宁静的地方。忽略那些觉醒派的宣传，去思考那些有缺陷但值得尊敬的人类的真实历史，他们现在都已安息。
然而，在这里，卡尤斯人却被描绘成魔法精灵，而非真正的人类。这种叙事试图为惠特曼夫妇的谋杀辩护，声称卡尤斯人拥有自己的世界，惠特曼医生召唤了邪灵，使他们染上麻疹。试想一下，如果我们用同样的逻辑来为清教徒烧死妇女的行为辩护，仅仅因为他们真心相信她们是女巫；或者为黑死病期间对犹太人的迫害辩护，仅仅因为他们真诚地相信犹太人在水井里投毒！为了反驳一个错误的叙事，觉醒派仅仅用一个同样错误的镜像来代替，而这个镜像正是他们声称憎恶的。
即便如此，这里仍然是一个美丽而宁静的地方。忽略那些觉醒派的宣传，去思考那些有缺陷但值得尊敬的人类的真实历史，他们现在都已安息。
© 2026 Tripadvisor 版权所有。
部分照片由 VFM Leonardo 提供。
TripAdvisor公司对外部网站的内容一概不负责。优惠价格中不含税和其他费用。
ICP证：沪B2-20200433
沪ICP备20013175号
沪公网安备31010502005427号鹰程信息技术（上海）有限公司
